Request a Demo and Enjoy a Free Trial→
ArchiWise
Honolulu Study Reveals How New Housing Triggers Price Drops and Vacancies in Older Units

Honolulu Study Reveals How New Housing Triggers Price Drops and Vacancies in Older Units

Honolulu, HawaiiSource: California YIMBY
MarketsPolicyResearch

A new study out of Honolulu provides evidence for the “filtering” effect in housing markets, demonstrating how new construction can lead to price drops and increased vacancies in older housing stock. Researchers Limin Fang, Emi Kim, and Justin Tyndall analyzed the impact of The Central, a 512-home tower completed in 2021, which includes 202 market-rate and 310 deed-restricted units.

The study found that homes vacated by residents moving into The Central experienced steep price drops, with first-round vacancies costing 38% less per square foot and second-round vacancies 44% less. While market-rate homes generated more moves and vacancies per unit (0.43) than income-restricted homes (0.29), vacancies from income-restricted units filtered into even lower price tiers. First residents of The Central often moved from neighborhoods with 15% lower median incomes, indicating a neighborhood upgrade.

Using a combination of pricing plans, property assessments, deed transfers, and address history, the researchers traced moving chains through four rounds. They credit Hawaiʻi’s 201H program for the project's viability, suggesting streamlined pathways and developer-absorbed discounts can replicate public housing benefits. However, they caution against setting affordability requirements too high, which could deter development. Over three years, this single building is linked to at least 180 confirmed vacancies, benefiting numerous households who never lived in the tower itself.

Topics

201h-programfilteringhousing-affordabilityhousing-supplyincome-restricted-housingmarket-rate-housingmoving-chains

More from Honolulu

More in Hawaii